Finding the Roots of Confusiasm

Over the years, the concept of “confusiasm” has become not only near and dear to my heart, but useful in so many ways that I never expected. It became a rallying cry for emergent, collaborative learning at a professional development project for professors at the University of Guadalajara (UdG Agora Project – confusiasmo! Translated!). It is a term that has been lovingly adopted by the Liberating Structures global network of practitioners. It has had its moments as a meme on Twitter.

Confusiasm is the happy coupling of confusion and enthusiasm. You know, that moment when something interesting is happening but you can’t quite understand it, but it feels really right. The verge of discovery. The hunch that in a messy, complex situation you are starting to see patterns that give you just enough confidence to keep moving forward and not give up.

Carl Jackson: the father of Confusiasm?

Because of the value it has accrued, I wanted to go back to my understanding of the roots of the word – when and where it was coined. My memory of it came from a game that emerged at one of the face-to-face gatherings of the KM4Dev (Knowledge management for development) community of practice, instigated by Carl Jackson, now of Westhill Knowledge in the UK. I think it was the 2006 Brighton gathering, but I’m not sure. It could have been Almada, Portugal in 2008. It starts showing up in websearches in 2008 so I suspect our play with the word was in 2006.

Carl has this uncanny ability to create portmanteaus, words. From Wikipedia: “a linguistic blend of words, in which parts of multiple words or their phonemes (sounds) are combined into a new word, as in smog, coined by blending smoke and fog,^[or motel, from motor and hotel.” All during the gathering he could coin them faster, and with a great deal more humor, than the rest of us. It was amazing!

So is that where confusiasm was born? I don’t really know. In the true spirit of Confusiasm, Carl wonders if it may have been our KM4Dev peer Ewen Le Borgne who coined the word at Almada. Ewen is that kind of human being too! So it is all possible. Ewen, what do you remember?

The earliest web reference to confusiasm I could find was actually a typo in a reference in a research paper, mispelling Confusianism with Confusiasm. (The paper was cited as Lim, C. and Lay, C.S. (2003) ”Confusiasm and the protestant work ethic”. Asia Europe Journal, Vol. 1, pp. 321-322. In the journal, the title is Confucianism and the Protestant Work Ethic)

Nowadays I see it in many places.

In today’s world, so much is messy and uncertain. Our ability to predict things is, well, paltry. But we have to keep going. So let’s marshal our confusiasm! Onward! And THANKS CARL!